• Chewy Chocolate Chip

  • Snickerdoodles

  • Peanut Butter

  • Key Lime Shortbread

  • Espresso Chocolate Chip Shortbread

  • Soft Sugar


  • Ultimate Brownies

  • Triple Layer Lemon Bars

  • Caramelitas

  • Browned Butter Rice Krispie Treats

Cupcakes and Cake Pops

  • Chocolate

  • Vanilla

  • Red Velvet

  • Margarita

  • Carrot Cake

  • German Chocolate


  • Homemade marshmallows

  • S'mores with homemade marshmallows

  • Hot cocoa bombs

  • Macarons

  • Cookie and Cupcake Kit (4 sugar cookies, 4 cupcakes, icings and sprinkles for DIY fun at home/gift)

Dessert Boxes and Dessert Boards


A variety of the above goodies, custom sized for your order. Let's talk and make it happen!

Get            Pricing


Other options available, just ask!


Providing sweetness for your next gathering, get-together, or gala!

The Goods

Kind words from kind people

"Karie can bake like no one else I know. She has spent years as a daughter, wife and mom perfecting the craft! She creates unique combinations and one-of-a-kind recipes to pack full of high quality ingredients that result in pure yuminess! Looking for made-from-scratch treats that taste amazing? Karie provides just what you're looking for!"

Michelle Meyer

"Always my go-to bakery when I need a sweet treat for a special event or just to spoil myself! People rave about these baked goods whenever they are at one of these events."

Cathy Kanitz, owner of Excellence in Music Studios

"At CrossWalk Church we wanted a way to let our first time guests know that they are special and appreciated. Butter Bakery gave us the perfect solution. Each week we take each guest a dozen gourmet cookies and they love them! Thanks Butter Bakery!"

Dan Solofra, Discipleship Pastor at CrossWalk Church

"You need to taste the real butter in these goodies. Sets a high standard for flavor."

Nancy Uhlhorn

"Butter Bakery has been delighting the teachers at Arizona Lutheran Academy with baked goodies for as long as we can remember. When a platter arrives with goodies, the rush to the break room is fast and furious as everyone just knows it'll be a delicious treat! From beautiful cakes to cupcakes to the most delectable cookies and new creations, she has mastered the baked goodie scene! ."

Jen Bode, Development Assistant at AZ Lutheran Academy